This is an archive of a past election.
See http://www.smartvoter.org/ca/sd/ for current information.
LWV League of Women Voters of California Education Fund If you appreciate our service to voters, please consider helping us with a donation.
Smart Voter
San Diego County, CA November 4, 2014 Election
Proposition K
Term Limits
City of La Mesa

Majority Approval Required

Pass: 9023 / 66.56% Yes votes ...... 4534 / 33.44% No votes

See Also: Index of all Propositions

Information shown below: Summary | Arguments | Full Text

Shall the Ordinance amending the La Mesa Municipal Code to impose a three consecutive terms limit on the office of City Council Member, Mayor or any combination of terms thereof be adopted?

Summary Prepared by City Attorney:
The La Mesa Municipal Code (Municipal Code) does not impose any type of a terms limit on the office of city council member, mayor, or any combination of terms thereof. Presently, therefore, an individual may seek election to the office of city council member, mayor, or any combination of terms thereof, for an unlimited number of terms.

This measure, placed on the ballot by a petition signed by the required number of voters, would amend the Municipal Code to impose a terms limit on the office of city council member, mayor, or any combination of terms thereof, in the following manner:

No person shall serve more than three consecutive terms of office as a member of the city council, or as mayor, or any combination thereof.

Any person who has served three consecutive terms as a member of the city council, mayor or any combination of terms thereof, shall not be eligible to serve another term until the expiration of a least four years.

The three consecutive terms limit shall apply prospectively only to those terms of office which commence on or after November 4, 2014.

If the measure is passed by the voters, it shall not be amended or repealed except by a majority vote of the voters of the City of La Mesa at a regularly scheduled election.

 
This election is archived. Any links to sources outside of Smart Voter may no longer be active. No further links will be added to this page.
Links to sources outside of Smart Voter are provided for information only and do not imply endorsement.

Arguments For Proposition K Arguments Against Proposition K
YES on Proposition K for La Mesa Term Limits to limit politicians to three consecutive terms as either Mayor or City Councilmember (or any combination thereof). After serving three consecutive terms (12 years) the politician must wait one term (4 years) before running for office again.

YES on K for Term Limits to take government back from career politicians. Politicians who spend too much time in office stop representing us, and start representing themselves. If they are periodically forced to return to normal civilian life, they will consider the long term effects of the legislation they impose on the rest of us.

YES on K for Term Limits to help ensure the voice of the people will be heard, not special interests. This allows new faces with fresh ideas and energy to serve our community. We need a City Council that reflects the diversity of our community. YES on K for Term Limits to help reduce career politicians overwhelming campaign advantages. High name recognition + regulatory power + special interest contributions + tip the scales against start-up candidates. Enough is enough! Prop K is democracy in action - this is your vote to limit career politicians.

YES on K for Term Limits because this ordinance is a measured balanced approach modeled after the state term limits law passed by La Mesa voters in June 2012. We have term limits for our President, Governor, State Legislators, and County Supervisors - why should our Mayor and Council be exempt?

Join the more than 4,000 La Mesa residents who signed petitions to put this initiative on the ballot. Let's help break the lifetime incumbent stranglehold on City Hall and return the keys of government to its rightful owners: the ordinary, hard-working, taxpaying citizens of La Mesa.

Vote YES on K for La Mesa Term Limits.

http://LaMesaTermLimits.com

KRISTINE ALESSIO
Councilmember, City of La Mesa
RUSSELL BUCKLEY
Retired Educator
Retired Navy Commander
SCOTT KIDWELL
I.B.E.W. Local 569 Electrician
Former La Mesa Community Service Commissioner
JOAN MCWHIRTER
Retired Nurse
BILL BABER
La Mesa - Spring Valley School District Trustee

Rebuttal to Arguments For
Why legislate mandatory turnover, when you have that opportunity every four years?

Proponents modeled their measure after the state, but that's exactly a model of what not to do.

Term Limits don't necessarily create citizen legislators, but they do create political musical chairs. The results produce inefficient government with a tendency to revisit issues, and a loss of knowledge that can result in increased influence by bureaucrats and special interests.

No matter the outcome of this election, there will be three people, a majority, with 0-2 years experience on our City Council.

Just because somebody's new doesn't mean they have integrity, any more than the opposite is true. If one is self-serving we can vote them out, if corrupt we can prosecute. The largest campaign contribution in city history went to a challenger, not an incumbent.

Eliminating candidates:

    • Lowers the level of candidate qualifications,
    • Makes it cheaper and easier for special interests to install their own candidates.

La Mesans have voted for good government for 100+ years + without term limits. There is no crisis we need to fix that warrants limiting the majority's right to choose. President Reagan called term limits "a mistake," saying, "I think that is an infringement on the democratic rights of the people... It is an invasion of their democratic rights to vote for whoever they want to vote for and for however long."

Vote NO on Prop K.

(1) ROBERT DUGGAN (2) KRISTIN KJAERO
(3) DEXTER LEVY (4) GARY NACH, Treasurer

NO TERM LIMITS - VOTE NO ON "K"

The First Amendment guarantees freedom of expression. Your vote allows you to put teeth behind your opinions.

Whether it's the nations founding, civil rights, suffragettes or other paths, your right to vote is a legacy of sacrifice and struggle far too precious to limit.

And that's what this measure does - it limits your ability to choose, not candidates' abilities to run.

This measure isn't about what you think of current council members. La Mesa has 100+ years of elections behind us, and who knows what the world will be in 2026 when this would take effect? This is about what legacy you'll pass along.

If one is concerned about "career politicians" this isn't the answer, and would come with seriously negative side effects.

Experience matters! Council's job is to direct staff but inexperience leaders defer more to staff, and term limits ensure that special interests have more experience than the people you elect.

In their last four years, councilmembers will have no need to be responsive to you, or tone down their rhetoric.

You can vote someone out now, but term limits would take away your right to retain someone if you believe they have merit.

The only people who would gain from this are those who want to eliminate competition, and special interests. That's no reason to limit your right to choose - don't give it away!

Endorsed by Dave Allen, retired City Councilman, Barbara Cleves Anderson, Mary Jane & Harold Bailey, Alison & Hal Drew, Helen Givens, Anthony Mc Ivor, Jim Melvin, Suzanne Merrill-Nach M.D., Donna Niemeier, Stuart Strenger & Crit Stuart.

For more information and endorsements, please visit: http://www.NoTermLimitsInLaMesa.com.
No Term Limits In La Mesa on Facebook
NoTermLimitsLM on Twitter

BOB DUGGAN KRISTIN KJAERO
Principal Officer
DEXTER LEVY GARY NACH
Treasurer

Rebuttal to Arguments Against
Vote Yes on K for La Mesa Terms Limits
if you believe politicians get more selfish and complacent the longer they stay in office. Term limits prevent any one career politician from amassing too much power over our lives.

Vote Yes on K for La Mesa Terms Limits
if you believe that three terms is a reasonable time to get the job done. If a politician can't achieve something for the public good in twelve years, it's time for a replacement. Vote Yes on K for La Mesa Terms Limits
if you believe that diversity on the City Council is healthy for our community.

Vote Yes on K for La Mesa Terms Limits
because long time Incumbents enjoy unfair electoral advantages over challengers. No La Mesa elected incumbent has been defeated in 24 years. Is that because they have been angels or because the game is rigged in their favor?

Vote Yes on K for La Mesa Terms Limits
If you agree that:

"Term limits would cure both senility and seniority + both terrible legislative diseases."
President Harry S. Truman

"After a time, civil servants tend to become no longer servants and no longer civil."
Winston Churchill

"In free governments, the rulers are the servants, and the people their superiors...
For the former to return among the latter does not degrade, but promote them."
Benjamin Franklin

"Politicians and diapers should be changed often, and for the same reason."
Mark Twain

Vote Yes on Proposition K for La Mesa Terms Limits!

http://LaMesaTermLimits.Com

KEVIN GEORGE
60 year La Mesa Resident and local business owner
RICHARD RIDER
Chairman, San Diego Tax Fighters
DONA CHRISTERNSEN
Independent Citizens Bond Oversight Committee
Grossmont Healthcare District
DENNIS TWISS
Retired Business Owner +
Graffiti Removal Services
CRAIG MAXWELL
Small Business Owner

Full Text of Proposition K
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE LA MESA MUNICIPAL CODE TO IMPOSE A THREE CONSECUTIVE TERMS LIMIT ON THE OFFICE OF CITY COUNCIL MEMBER, MAYOR, OR ANY COMBINATION OF TERMS THEREOF

_______________________________________________________________________

THE PEOPLE OF THE CITY OF LA MESA DO ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS:

SECTION 1. The La Mesa Municipal Code is hereby amended to add Chapter 2.14 to be known as the "Three Consecutive Terms Limit" Ordinance.

SECTION 2.

"Chapter 2.14

THREE CONSECUTIVE TERMS LIMIT

2.14.010 No person shall serve more than three consecutive terms of office as a member of the city council, or as mayor, or any combination of terms thereof.

2.14.011 Any person who has served three consecutive terms as a member of the city council, or as mayor, or any combination of terms thereof, shall not be eligible to serve again until the expiration of at least four years.

2.14.012 Any person who is elected or appointed to an unexpired term as a member of the city council, or as mayor, who serves more than one-half of a full term of office shall be deemed to have served a full term.

2.14.013 Any member of the city council, or mayor, who resigns or is removed from office during a term shall be deemed to have served a full term.

2.14.014 The three consecutive terms limit established by this chapter shall apply prospectively only to those terms of office which commence on or after November 4, 2014.

2.14.015 If any part of this chapter is held by a court of law of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, the remaining parts of this chapter shall remain in full force and effect.

2.14.016 This chapter shall not be amended or repealed except by a majority vote of the voters of the City of La Mesa at a regularly scheduled election.

SECTION 3. If the provisions of this ordinance are in conflict with the provisions of any other ordinance adopted at the same election, the ordinance receiving the highest number of affirmative votes shall control."


San Diego Home Page || Statewide Links || About Smart Voter || Feedback
Created: July 23, 2015 14:58 PDT
Smart Voter <http://www.smartvoter.org/>
Copyright © League of Women Voters of California Education Fund   http://cavotes.org
The League of Women Voters neither supports nor opposes candidates for public office or political parties.